I recently ran into a problem when trying to apply a base build to a Cisco 7600 router with dual supervisors which didn't seem to be documented anywhere, so I thought I'd record the issue and the eventual fix here.
The gist of the problem was that the secondary supervisor would not go from cold standby to hot, so in other words if the active supervisor crashed, the chassis would have to reboot in order to use the standby supervisor. The system was showing the reason for this as software mismatch, even though the two cards had the same image installed:
BUILD#show redundancy states
my state = 13 -ACTIVE
peer state = 4 -STANDBY COLD
Mode = Duplex
Unit = Primary
Unit ID = 5
Redundancy Mode (Operational) = rpr Reason: Software mismatch
Redundancy Mode (Configured) = sso
Redundancy State = rpr
Maintenance Mode = Disabled
Communications = Up
client count = 159
client_notification_TMR = 30000 milliseconds
keep_alive TMR = 9000 milliseconds
keep_alive count = 1
keep_alive threshold = 18
RF debug mask = 0x0
I won't say exactly which image this was, but it was an SSO-capable relase of IOS 15 and the two supervisors were *definitely* running the same code (one was copied from the other). The tale of software incompatibility seemed unlikely.
BUILD#show log
[snip]
*Jan 6 17:21:33.339: %SYS-SP-STDBY-5-RESTART: System restarted --
Cisco IOS Software, c7600s72033_sp Software (c7600s72033_sp-ADVIPSERVICESK9-M), Version 15.x(x)x, RELEASE SOFTWARE (xx)
Technical Support: http://www.cisco.com/techsupport
Copyright (c) 1986-2012 by Cisco Systems, Inc.
Compiled Mon 00-Jan-00 00:00 by prod_rel_team
*Jan 6 17:22:50.255 GMT: Config Sync: Bulk-sync failure due to Servicing Incompatibility. Please check full list of mismatched commands via:
show redundancy config-sync failures mcl
*Jan 6 17:22:50.255 GMT: Config Sync: Starting lines from MCL file:
-ipv6 mfib hardware-switching replication-mode ingress
*Jan 6 17:22:50.255 GMT: %ISSU-SP-3-INCOMPATIBLE_PEER_UID: Setting image (c7600s72033_sp-ADVIPSERVICESK9-M), version (15.x(x)xx) on peer uid (6) as incompatible
*Jan 6 17:22:50.995 GMT: %RF-SP-5-RF_RELOAD: Peer reload. Reason: ISSU Incompatibility
*Jan 6 17:22:50.995 GMT: %OIR-SP-3-PWRCYCLE: Card in module 6, is being power-cycled (RF request)
*Jan 6 17:22:51.999 GMT: %PFREDUN-SP-6-ACTIVE: Standby processor removed or reloaded, changing to Simplex mode
*Jan 6 17:22:53.195 GMT: %SNMP-5-MODULETRAP: Module 6 [Down] Trap
*Jan 6 17:24:19.791 GMT: %ISSU-SP-3-PEER_IMAGE_INCOMPATIBLE: Peer image (c7600s72033_sp-ADVIPSERVICESK9-M), version (15.x(x)xx) on peer uid (6) is incompatible
*Jan 6 17:24:19.791 GMT: %ISSU-SP-3-PEER_IMAGE_INCOMPATIBLE: Peer image (c7600s72033_sp-ADVIPSERVICESK9-M), version (15.x(x)xx) on peer uid (6) is incompatible
*Jan 6 17:25:53.149 GMT: %PFREDUN-SP-4-INCOMPATIBLE: Defaulting to RPR mode (Runtime incompatible)
*Jan 6 17:25:54.154 GMT: %PFREDUN-SP-6-ACTIVE: Standby initializing for RPR mode
*Jan 6 17:25:58.471 GMT: %SYS-SP-3-LOGGER_FLUSHED: System was paused for 00:00:00 to ensure console debugging output.
*Jan 6 17:25:58.763 GMT: %FABRIC-SP-5-CLEAR_BLOCK: Clear block option is off for the fabric in slot 6.
*Jan 6 17:25:58.859 GMT: %FABRIC-SP-5-FABRIC_MODULE_BACKUP: The Switch Fabric Module in slot 6 became standby
*Jan 6 17:26:00.299 GMT: %SNMP-5-MODULETRAP: Module 6 [Up] Trap
*Jan 6 17:26:00.279 GMT: %DIAG-SP-6-BYPASS: Module 6: Diagnostics is bypassed
*Jan 6 17:26:00.375 GMT: %OIR-SP-6-INSCARD: Card inserted in slot 6, interfaces are now online
*Jan 6 17:26:06.435 GMT: %RF-SP-5-RF_TERMINAL_STATE: Terminal state reached for (RPR)
OK, so clearly it doesn't like the "ipv6 mfib hardware-switching replication-mode ingress" command for some reason. Why it would work on one and not the other is a mystery but hey... I don't have big plans for IPv6 multicast so I don't care what replication mode it's in - let's just delete the offending command:
BUILD#conf t
Enter configuration commands, one per line. End with CNTL/Z.
BUILD(config)#no ipv6 mfib hardware-switching replication-mode ingress
no ipv6 mfib hardware-switching replication-mode ingress
^
% Invalid input detected at '^' marker.
So I can't negate the command, in fact there's no "mfib" stanza under "no ipv6":
BUILD(config)#no ipv6 ?
access-list Configure access lists
[snip]
local Specify local options
mld Global mld commands
[snip]
spd Selective Packet Discard (SPD)
In fact, even the original command seems to be invalid:
BUILD(config)#ipv6 mfib hardware-switching replication-mode ?
% Unrecognized command
And yet here it is in the config from which we booted:
BUILD#show start | inc ipv6
ipv6 unicast-routing
ipv6 mfib hardware-switching replication-mode ingress
no mls flow ipv6
?!?!
I guess it's one of those legacy commands they bodge the CLI to take but you can't see in the help. But it won't take the command anyway :| Eventually I found an equivalent command that it *would* take:
BUILD(config)#no ipv6 multicast hardware-switching replication-mode ingress
Warning: This command will change the replication mode for all address families.
BUILD(config)#do show run | inc ipv6
ipv6 unicast-routing
no mls flow ipv6
BUILD(config)#
At last, the problem config is gone! We're almost there but not quite, the previous failures sit in the active supervisor even if the standby is reloaded so we have to kick it to re-evaluate:
BUILD#show redundancy config-sync failures mcl
Mismatched Command List
-----------------------
-ipv6 mfib hardware-switching replication-mode ingress
BUILD#redundancy config-sync validate mismatched-commands
*Jan 7 08:26:28.600 GMT: CONFIG SYNC: MCL validation succeeded
*Jan 7 08:26:28.600 GMT: %ISSU-SP-3-PEER_IMAGE_REM_FROM_INCOMP_LIST: Peer image (c7600s72033_sp-ADVIPSERVICESK9-M), version (15.x(x)xx) on peer uid (6) being removed from the incompatibility list
BUILD#show redundancy config-sync failures mcl
Mismatched Command List
-----------------------
The list is Empty
BUILD#redundancy reload peer
Reload peer [confirm]
Preparing to reload peer
BUILD#
*Jan 7 08:27:16.096 GMT: RP sending reload request to Standby. User: admin on console, Reason: Admin reload CLI
BUILD#
Eventually...
*Jan 7 08:33:37.532 GMT: %HA_CONFIG_SYNC-6-BULK_CFGSYNC_SUCCEED: Bulk Sync succeeded*Jan 7 08:33:37.552 GMT: %RF-SP-5-RF_TERMINAL_STATE: Terminal state reached for (SSO)
*Jan 7 08:33:36.572 GMT: %PFREDUN-SP-STDBY-6-STANDBY: Ready for SSO mode
BUILD#show redundancy
Redundant System Information :
------------------------------
Available system uptime = 15 hours, 20 minutes
Switchovers system experienced = 0
Standby failures = 3
Last switchover reason = none
Hardware Mode = Duplex
Configured Redundancy Mode = sso
Operating Redundancy Mode = sso
Maintenance Mode = Disabled
Communications = Up
Current Processor Information :
-------------------------------
Active Location = slot 5
Current Software state = ACTIVE
Uptime in current state = 15 hours, 19 minutes
Image Version = Cisco IOS Software, c7600s72033_rp Software (c7600s72033_rp-ADVIPSERVICESK9-M), Version 15.x(x)xx, RELEASE SOFTWARE (fc2)
Technical Support: http://www.cisco.com/techsupport
Copyright (c) 1986-2012 by Cisco Systems, Inc.
Compiled Wed 01-Aug-12 20:15 by prod_rel_team
BOOT = sup-bootdisk:/c7600s72033-advipservicesk9-mz.15x-x.xx.bin,1;
CONFIG_FILE =
BOOTLDR =
Configuration register = 0x2102
Peer Processor Information :
----------------------------
Standby Location = slot 6
Current Software state = STANDBY HOT
Uptime in current state = 3 minutes
Image Version = Cisco IOS Software, c7600s72033_rp Software (c7600s72033_rp-ADVIPSERVICESK9-M), Version 15.x(x)xx, RELEASE SOFTWARE (fc2)
Technical Support: http://www.cisco.com/techsupport
Copyright (c) 1986-2012 by Cisco Systems, Inc.
Compiled Wed 01-Aug-12 20:15 by prod_rel_team
BOOT = sup-bootdisk:/c7600s72033-advipservicesk9-mz.15x-x.xx.bin,1;
CONFIG_FILE =
BOOTLDR =
Configuration register = 0x2102
BUILD#
Win!
Showing posts with label supervisor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label supervisor. Show all posts
Sunday, 31 January 2016
Saturday, 11 July 2015
Testing the Impact of Local Packet Capture on the Cisco 6500 Series
For a while now, many of the larger Cisco devices (such as 6500 and 7600s) have supported local packet capture. I've always been hesitant to use these in a production environment, primarily due to concerns about the potential performance hit it could cause. Anyway, I decided to test out the potential impact in the lab to see whether it was sometimes / always / never safe to run local captures.
The configuration was as follows:
Running at full tilt, Ostinato was happily producing 1 Gbps of traffic which went into my node on VLAN 100, out around the loop cable, back into the node and then out of the same interface on VLAN 101. Basically the port is running at 1 Gbps in each direction, so the worst possible case for mirroring a gig port.
Now we have a the best and the worst cases, let's look at some realistic use cases and explore some of the other capture parameters that might help us capture what we need without causing havoc on the network.
Just for fun let's try the same with a hardware ACL filter:
So the filter throws out the junk before the rate limiter, meaning that the rate limiter only counts the good stuff. If the good stuff exceeds the rate limit then you'll lose some of it but the junk doesn't count.
Compare that to the flow for the software filters:
The software filters are applied after the rate limiter, so clearly when the rate limit is exceeded you throw out a mix of good and bad traffic, then pick out what's left of the good. If your traffic is overwhelmingly garbage, you may not get any of the good stuff at all!
Test Setup
For my test setup I used a 6504-E switch with a modest SUP32-GE-3B supervisor and a 12.2 Advanced IP Services IOS - if it works on that, it should be safe anywhere. For traffic, I used a spare server running Ubuntu with a combination of Ostinato and Scapy.The configuration was as follows:
Default Settings
The default settings for the capture are pretty conservative - a tiny 2 MB linear capture buffer with a rate limit of 10,000 frames per second. With this config, a 1 Gbps stream of 1500 byte packets fills the buffer in ~ 2.5s, triggering the capture to end. The impact of this is almost impossible to measure at all, with the capture being over so quickly you may not actually see any change in CPU on the 5 second roll-ups.Lab-6503E#monitor capture start
*Jul 11 14:30:59.205: %SPAN-5-PKTCAP_START: Packet capture session 1 started
Lab-6503E#
*Jul 11 14:31:01.449: %SPAN-5-PKTCAP_STOP: Packet capture session 1 ended as the buffer is full, 21845 packets captured
Lab-6503E#show proc cpu hist
222223333322222 8888811
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10 *****
0....5....1....1....2....2....3....3....4....4....5....5....
0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5
CPU% per second (last 60 seconds)
Worst Case
OK, so the world didn't end. The next step was to see how bad it could be so I made the following changes:- Increased the rate limit to 100,000 fps (max)
- Increased the packet buffer to 64 MB (max)
- Enabled a circular buffer (why?!)
Lab-6503E#monitor capture circular buffer size 65535 start for 60 sec
*Jul 11 14:45:02.953: %SPAN-5-PKTCAP_START: Packet capture session 1 started
*Jul 11 14:46:02.945: %SPAN-5-PKTCAP_STOP: Packet capture session 1 ended after the specified time, 699040 packets captured
Lab-6503E#show proc cpu hist
2222244444444444444455555444444444444444444444444444444444
9999999999888889999966666999999999999999999998888899999999
100
90
80
70
60 *****
50 *****************************************************
40 *****************************************************
30 **********************************************************
20 **********************************************************
10 **********************************************************
0....5....1....1....2....2....3....3....4....4....5....5....
0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5
CPU% per second (last 60 seconds)
The impact to the supervisor in this case was much more noticeable - up to 60% CPU utilisation. The scenario is pretty unrealistic (forget circular buffers!) but suffice to say I wouldn't want to do that on a production device.Now we have a the best and the worst cases, let's look at some realistic use cases and explore some of the other capture parameters that might help us capture what we need without causing havoc on the network.
Narrowing Down the Capture
It's possible to define criteria to decide what gets captured - as the CLI points out, some of these criteria are processed in hardware while others are handled in software:Lab-6503E(config-mon-capture)#filter ? access-group Filter access-list (hardware based) ethertype Matching ethertype (software based) length Matching L2-packet length (software based) mac-address Matching mac-address (software-based) vlan Filter vlan (hardware based)Our test traffic consists of nearly a gig of junk run alongside a small 1-per-second ping, which we will decide is "interesting" to us and we want to capture. This traffic profile makes it easy to test ACL, MAC address and length filters and their relative performances.
ACL Filter
As the CLI says, ACL filters are applied in hardware so the junk is discarded at source before it hits the CPU. In this example I set up an ACL as follows:Lab-6503E(config)#ip access-list extended icmp-only Lab-6503E(config-ext-nacl)#permit icmp any any Lab-6503E(config-ext-nacl)#deny ip any any... and applied it to my capture as follows:
Lab-6503E(config)#monitor session 1 Lab-6503E(config-mon-capture)#filter access-group icmp-onlyNow, I re-ran the "worst case" test, with massively different results:
Lab-6503E#monitor capture circular buffer size 65535 start for 60 sec
*Jul 11 14:49:00.345: %SPAN-5-PKTCAP_START: Packet capture session 1 started
*Jul 11 14:50:00.337: %SPAN-5-PKTCAP_STOP: Packet capture session 1 ended after the specified time, 60 packets captured
Lab-6503E#show proc cpu hist
22222222223333355555 11111
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10 *****
0....5....1....1....2....2....3....3....4....4....5....5....
0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5
CPU% per second (last 60 seconds)
Two things to note here - because this is a hardware filter, applied in the ASICs:- Only 1 packet per second was punted to the CPU, resulting in essentially no hit at all
- All 60 of the ping packets were received and nothing else
MAC Filter
In contrast, the MAC filter runs in software. It's also pretty limited, only matching on source MAC. I repeated the above test but instead of an ACL match, applied a MAC filter as follows:Lab-6503E(config)#monitor session 1 Lab-6503E(config-mon-capture)#filter mac-address 0011.2233.4455This took us more-or-less back to the worst case:
Lab-6503E#monitor capture circular buffer size 65535 start for 60 sec
*Jul 11 15:05:55.197: %SPAN-5-PKTCAP_START: Packet capture session 1 started
*Jul 11 15:06:55.189: %SPAN-5-PKTCAP_STOP: Packet capture session 1 ended after the specified time, 5 packets captured
Lab-6503E#show proc cpu hist
44444444443333344444333334444444444444444444444444333333
4422222111119999900000999990000011111333331111111111888889
100
90
80
70
60
50
40 ********************************************************
30 ********************************************************
20 ********************************************************
10 ********************************************************
0....5....1....1....2....2....3....3....4....4....5....5....
0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5
CPU% per second (last 60 seconds)
Yuck. I wouldn't do that in production. This is basically because the software filters are applied after the packets have been punted to the CPU, so you pay a penalty for the garbage as well as the good stuff. You'll notice that it only captured 5 packets as well, more on this later but that's another side effect of software filters.Length Filter
The frame length filter is another software-based mechanism, which means it's pretty terrible under load, too. Our junk traffic consists of large frames, our interesting traffic is small, so let's configure the capture to only catch the short frames:Lab-6503E(config)#monitor session 1 Lab-6503E(config-mon-capture)#filter length 0 100Again, the output is pretty miserable:
Lab-6503E#monitor capture circular buffer size 65535 start for 60 sec
*Jul 11 15:15:12.145: %SPAN-5-PKTCAP_START: Packet capture session 1 started
*Jul 11 15:16:12.137: %SPAN-5-PKTCAP_STOP: Packet capture session 1 ended after the specified time, 17 packets captured
Lab-6503E#show proc cpu hist
1111444443333344444444443333333333333333333333333444443333
4444000009999911111222229999999999999999999999999222229999
100
90
80
70
60
50
40 ******************************************************
30 ******************************************************
20 ******************************************************
10 **********************************************************
0....5....1....1....2....2....3....3....4....4....5....5....
0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5
CPU% per second (last 60 seconds)
Again, the CPU took a hammering and we only captured a few of the ping packets - 17 out of 60.Quirks / Order of Operations
Now you may think that software filters might be OK if we just reduce the rate-limit configured on the capture:Lab-6503E(config)#monitor session 1 Lab-6503E(config-mon-capture)#rate-limit 100This *does* do what we want for the CPU load - here's an example with a MAC filter:
Lab-6503E#monitor capture circular buffer size 65535 start for 60 sec
*Jul 11 15:26:43.793: %SPAN-5-PKTCAP_START: Packet capture session 1 started
*Jul 11 15:27:43.785: %SPAN-5-PKTCAP_STOP: Packet capture session 1 ended after the specified time, 0 packets captured
Lab-6503E#show proc cpu hist
11111 11111 6666633333
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10 *****
0....5....1....1....2....2....3....3....4....4....5....5....
0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5 0 5
CPU% per second (last 60 seconds)
Great - nothing to see here. But also nothing to see in the capture buffer - 0 packets captured!Just for fun let's try the same with a hardware ACL filter:
*Jul 11 15:25:26.921: %SPAN-5-PKTCAP_STOP: Packet capture session 1 ended after the specified time, 60 packets capturedWhy is this? Well, it's the order of operations. Basically the flow for hardware ACL filters is:
Compare that to the flow for the software filters:
Summary - Play it Safe
So in answer to the question "is it safe to run a local capture on a production 6500" - packet capture on even a relatively modest SUP32-3B supervisor is pretty safe provided you are cautious. If you want to do this in a busy production environment then my message to you is:- Use ACLs where at all possible
- Set the rate limit to a sensible value (the default 1000 fps is fine for most cases)
- Use linear buffers of a sensible size (do you really need 64MB of capture?)
- Limit the frame count or capture duration at first (it may turn out there is a lot more "interesting" traffic than you thought!)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)